Additional Context

Actors

Banks · Payment Networks · Corporate Treasury · Liquidity Providers · Regulators · Stablecoin Issuers

Problems

Problem 1: Trading Intent and Front-Running Prevention

FX markets are highly competitive with tight spreads. Leaked trading intent enables front-running and adverse price movements.

Requirements:

  • Must hide: Order size, direction, timing, counterparty relationships
  • Public OK: General market liquidity, executed trade existence (after settlement)
  • Regulator access: Trade reporting for market surveillance; sanctions screening

Constraints:

  • Real-time settlement requirements
  • Liquidity fragmentation across stablecoin venues
  • Regulatory reporting obligations for FX derivatives: forwards, swaps and options are reportable under EMIR (Art. 9; currency derivatives per MiFID II Annex I C(4)) and Dodd-Frank (OTC FX options are swaps under the CFTC/SEC product definitions; the Treasury FX determination, 2012 exempts FX swaps and forwards from clearing but not trade reporting); spot FX (delivery within two trading days for major pairs, Delegated Regulation (EU) 2017/565 Art. 10; T+2 in US practice.

Problem 2: Cross-Border Settlement Privacy

International payments reveal business relationships and transaction patterns that competitors can exploit.

Requirements:

  • Must hide: Payment amounts, sender/receiver identities, payment purpose
  • Public OK: Settlement finality confirmation
  • Regulator access: AML/CFT monitoring; cross-border transaction reporting

Constraints:

  • Multi-jurisdictional compliance requirements
  • Correspondent banking relationships
  • SWIFT alternative positioning

Recommended Approaches

See Private Trade Settlement for general settlement architecture. FX-specific considerations:

To keep trading intent out of the public mempool before inclusion (Problem 1), see Approach: Private Transaction Broadcasting.

Open Questions

  • How does privacy interact with real-time gross settlement requirements?
  • What's the role of central bank digital currencies vs private stablecoins?
  • How to handle multi-currency atomic swaps with privacy?

Notes And Links